As we wrote in a previous On the Subject, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals had signaled that it might rehear its August 2019 decisions in Dorman v. The Charles Schwab Corp., in which the Court compelled arbitration of ERISA class-action claims relating to a 401(k) plan. After ordering additional briefing, however, the Ninth Circuit denied the plaintiff’s petition for rehearing, leaving the Court’s decisions unchanged and requiring the plaintiff to arbitrate his ERISA breach-of-fiduciary-duty claims.
Ninth Circuit Decides Not to Rehear Its Decision Requiring Arbitration of ERISA Claims
By Richard J. Pearl and Ted Becker on December 19, 2019

Rick Pearl focuses his practice on litigation involving the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA). He represents companies, their benefits committees, plan administrators, fiduciaries, and service providers in complex, class-action litigation and Department of Labor lawsuits, audits, and investigations. His particular expertise is with actions for breach of fiduciary duty and prohibited transactions. Read Rick Pearl's full bio.

Ted Becker focuses his practice on litigation under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) and related federal and state actions, and defense of government investigations and audits relating to employee benefit, health and welfare, and retirement plans brought by the US Department of Labor, the Internal Revenue Service, and the US Department of Justice. He is a leading voice and nationally recognized practitioner in this complex practice area. He has represented public and private companies that sponsor employee benefit, health and welfare, and retirement plans governed by ERISA, and their directors and officers and plan fiduciaries, as well as service providers to ERISA plans and plan sponsors. He has extensive experience in Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) and has defended some of the highest profile lawsuits involving ESOPs, helping to define the landscape of the evolving law relating to ESOPs. Read Ted Becker's full bio.
Related Posts
- SCOTUS Holds Proof of ‘Actual Knowledge’ Required Under ERISA Statute of Limitations
- The Biggest ERISA Decisions of 2019
- Inflation and ERISA Penalties: Hand in Hand for 2022
- COVID-19 Ate My Homework – Recent Extensions and Relief for Retirement Plans
- Ninth Circuit Answers Some Questions About Arbitration of ERISA Claims
BLOG EDITORS
STAY CONNECTED
TOPICS
ARCHIVES
RECENT POSTS
- Bipartisan Health Bills Pick Up Steam, but Contentious Debt Ceiling Negotiations Continue
- CMS Ups Hospital Price Transparency Enforcement, Seeks More Authority from Congress
- May Trending in Telehealth
- Update Future Financing Act – Focus on Employee Participation in Germany
- Addressing DOJ’s New Compliance Focus on Executive Compensation

